While I wish that there was an exciting alternative to boring old beams, they are probably the best form of suspension for low-speed off roading, particular in portal or de-dion incarnations to get those diffs out of the way. As you can see from the pictures of me trying to put that red Pinz on its roof while attempting a trials section laid out for LandRovers, Pinzgauers are best at going quick over marginal terrain, and rely heavily on diff locks and bravery to go over anything seriously lumpy. Their high CoG and limited travel can make them look pretty stupid if you drive at things as you would a Land Rover; at least that's the excuse I like to use :-) Will, if you're still interested in seeing the dirty bits of a Pinz axle, I'll post some pics on Monday.
Undoubtedly, given large sums of money and active suspension, an independent can be made to act like a beam at low speeds but why not just use a beam in the first place? I'm afraid these fine gentlemen have done some extravagant beard stroking and concluded the same thing:
"SAE Technical Papers
Title: Independent Versus Axle Suspension for On/Off Road Vehicles
Document Number: 921662
Author(s):
D. A. Crolla - University of Leeds
G. R. Firth - University of Leeds
D. N. L. Horton - University of Leeds
Abstract:
The conflicting suspension requirements of vehicles which are designed for both on and off-road operation are examined. The example vehicle used throughout the calculations is a six-wheel truck of 24 tonne GVW and is based on an existing crash tender design. Using the vehicle dynamics analysis software (VDAS) package, the ride and handling behaviour of the truck is analysed for two versions of the vehicle; one with three axles suspended on lead springs with a bogie arrangement at the rear, and another with independent wheel suspension throughout.
The overall conclusion drawn is that axle designs have significant advantages for off-road vehicle applications; they maintain good ground clearance, they are based on inexpensive, well proven technology and, with attention to detail deisgn, offer vehicle dynamic performance comparable with independent designs. On the other hand, if the optimum ride and handling compromise for on-road conditions is a priority, then the independent suspension may be worth the additional investment. "
Anyway don't let me or the beard strokers stop you trying, innovation is good.