Jump to content

Ex Member

Guest
  • Posts

    3,446
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    15

Posts posted by Ex Member

  1. 3 hours ago, Daan said:

    I think, looking at that video that is plenty capable for 99% of the buying public. If they get the looks right, it will be winner in my opinion.

    For the people that want more, there will be plenty of aftermarket business for coil conversions, lift kits, bash plates, live axle swaps etc later on. This is a good thing imo. I don't think it is all as bad as the 18 pages of hate mail would suggest. 

    You are missing the point.  They should be creating a vehicle that is better off road than the previous model AND better off road than any other vehicle being sold for road use today.  It should be a world killer.  They should be setting a new benchmark that other would need to catch up to.  While still being acceptable to drive on road by today's standards.  They are not doing that.

    • Like 2
  2. Except, independent suspension with short arms is worse than live axles off road.  This is just a plain simple fact.  If you disagree, you don't understand the physics or do not have the experience.

    Multi link live axles with coil or air springs works better than leaves.  Leaves as springs can be made to work, but there are still compromises and you really need to add some linkage and at that point, there is no reason to use them anymore.  Leaves were used as they provide a simple linkage and spring in one, not because they were the best solution.

    These are pictures of the Defender.  Production has started...  This is not R&D.  It is just reliability checks.

    As to the D5, this is a picture of one with the bumper off.  Nobody with ten minutes of off road experience would put oil cooler in front of the front wheels.

     

    c194d1b368e19ad6d3611e8c70770624.jpg

  3. Things that contribute to loose steering.....

    - Steering shaft joints.  Already replaced

    - Internal steering box free play.  Adjust as per the manual to remove.

    - Tie rod ends.  Hold each of the four joints while someone moves steering back and forth.  It is easy to feel if any are loose.

    - Panhard rod bushings worn or loose bolts.

    - Loose hub bearings.  Make sure they have a bit of preload.

    - Swivel bearings.  Make sure they have a bit of preload.

    With everything good, there should be very little play at the wheel.  The tyre sidewall should be the main thing at that point.

  4. 2 hours ago, miketomcat said:

    I stand corrected however you can just split the casing and rotate to change the handing. The britpart upgrade kit looks to be the same as the Mondeo alternator but the other hand so the case will need to be split and rotated.

    Mike

    Only if they are a 3 bolt casing.  Most casings are 4 bolt, so this does not work. A whole lot of work when you can just buy one that works...

    For a Disco 200TDI, you can simply buy the 100 Amp alternator for a 300TDI.

  5. 33 minutes ago, FridgeFreezer said:

    The fan thing was more about the on/off thermal shock rather than the gradual increase/decrease  with temperature you get with the viscous, changing the sensing point etc. won't change that - you'd need a variable speed fan (which LR did on the Freelander) or possibly electric water pump (ugh) to achieve that.

    The viscous unit is an on/off control device.  It is not gradual.  It is no different to an electric fan cycling on and off.  I'm not sure that you understand how a viscous unit works.

  6. 3 hours ago, ballcock said:

    This is a different can of worms. The fan only needs to run if the radiator is not doing its job. That is how the viscous unit works, so the temp control should be on the return or low level on the radiator. a better system would be a two stage temp control with either two fans or high and low speeds. Let the fight begin.

    I'm sorry but you are wrong.  I've been designing complex control systems for decades and building and designing testing facilities.  Controlling on the engine temperature is the correct way and prevents swings in engine temperature leading to shock. This is how every car with an electric fan built in the world works.

  7. 4 hours ago, FridgeFreezer said:

    Usually I'd say the same but I've heard credible suggestions that electric fans create too sudden a cooling effect on TDi's and lead to the head gasket failing...

    That is people setting up the fan control wrong.  They use the radiator outlet temperature as the control.  You want to use the inlet line as it is the engine temperature you are controlling, not the radiator.  With the control in the right place, there are no temperature swings beyond what is normally seen with a thermostat.

    You certainly need a good fan in certain situations.  Off road is most situation, it is needed.  Any long climbs that are not at motorway speed.  Basically any situation that you use it for what it was intended....

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience. By using our website you agree to our Cookie Policy