Jump to content

dailysleaze

Settled In
  • Posts

    999
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

Posts posted by dailysleaze

  1. I've had britpart caliper seals when ordering genuine before, but they sent out the genuine ones straight away once realised. Albeit same order they sent delphi brake pads when it said mintex. I argued the toss as i wanted mintex and it said mintex, but they argued that they're a similar quality, which i guess is true so i left it. I don't suspect that their website is 100% accurate all the time, but i've dealt with worse retailers before

  2. After I received a damaged genuine crankshaft seal this week, I believe the supplier's returns policy goes a long way towards the value in the price.

    The retailer has sent out a replacement straight away just from a photo, and doesn't require the damaged item back. I suspect for the retailer they have more flexibility in how to operate and LR's returns policy is quite trusting. Presumably because they don't expect many failures, they will always give the benefit of the doubt and warrant them on a small amount of evidence and are insured to this effect,

    With the larger box companies the retailers have to collect the item and send it back for inspection before issuing any refund, causing pain for the retailer and user, but the company is protecting itself because they have so many failures. I've had to go through this many times and it's a massive pain when all you want is another part. It's also a case that if it's too much hassle then people might not even bother returning the item and suck up the loss because it'd be quicker to buy a new part rather than go through returns and refunds.

  3. Opened the bag with scissors well away from the seal. I'm resigned to the fact that the job will have to wait til I can get another genuine seal. It's just annoying when you try to prevent part problems by buying the best quality part! Looking at nitrile as a material, it can't really cope with temperatures beyond 100 celcius, which must be pretty close to some engine temps

    I've also managed to mash up my ERR7143 front cover seal trying to fit it. I'm thinking of going back to ERR4576 oil seal for ease

  4. I'm doing the timing belt on my 300Tdi, and inspired by this recent thread I bought a genuine and pattern crankshaft seal ERR4575 to see what the difference is. Comparing them and seeing that the £13.50 genuine seal appeared to be the browny Viton material compared to the £1.50 more blackish nitrile material I had a smug sense of satisfaction.

    Surprisingly though, the cheaper nitrile seal is *identical*. It even has the part number stamped in it.

    post-18025-0-45994200-1391257173_thumb.jpg

    They even look more alike than the seal that came off the vehicle, which has been leaking

    post-18025-0-86824500-1391257174_thumb.jpg

    However, when going to fit the Genuine seal this morning, I noticed that there are two splits in it!

    post-18025-0-85678500-1391257175_thumb.jpg

    Now, normally the solution is obvious - send it back, wait and get a new one before carrying on. It's annoying as i'd allocated this weekend to doing the job. The problem is, the Genuine part is the one that's poor quality. The fact that the cheaper part is identical apart from the material it's very tempting to think "It should be alright"? The markings are the same:

    post-18025-0-33627200-1391257171_thumb.jpg

    I guess the question is, is Nitrile an acceptable material for a crankshaft seal or should I wait for a (I presume Viton) Genuine seal, which at the moment doesn't have good track record of quality? Although the seal that came off the vehicle that was leaking appears to be black like it's nitrile.

    Usually it'd be a easy decision, but there's a couple extra things in the mix with this scenario! :huh:

  5. If you can't stand water, mud, and the smell of farming, bugger off out of the countryside!

    Well said. Too many people move to the country and try to make it just like London.

    There has been a change in policy in recent times to not spend money on trying to defend against nature. You will not win in the long run. E.g. money spent on carting beaches down the east coast to protect homes, to see it being washed back up by longshore drift. How's that not a waste of money?

    Hundreds of years ago the Somerset levels were a tidal marsh. Man conquered it by draining them and turning it into farmland but you can't beat nature. Less has been spent on dredging the rivers as it has proven ineffective for the sorts of rain that cause flooding anyway. Better off not spending the money in the first place. Everyone that buys a house these days gets a sheet of paper detailing that property's flood risk. It's up to the homeowner to judge that risk.

    Take the village of Muchelney, the -ey suffix denotes "island" in Old English. Of all the old villages that we've seen flooding of, the church that's been there hundreds of years never gets flooded. Funny that! Building on flood plains is stupid. It all comes back to population growth.

    Don't worry it'll snow next year and we can all have a go about that again.

  6. Because the 'box company's haven't commented, that is all the more reason why a thread with an attention grabbing title should be started to raise awareness about this Carp before someone gets killed!

    I will be endeavouring to have this swivel ball subject raised on the widely read Australian AULRO forum.

    I came across this thread where a new poster "bluebear" was defending Britpart, but was outed as an employee.

    This page onwards: http://www.fullfatrr.com/forum/topic13598-15.html

    They hardly have a very good social media strategy! He was making the excuse that because they are a wholesaler, it's not their job to deal with the end user. :rofl:

  7. I think defenders in particular being easy to fix is due to the bolt on/off nature of the parts and highly separated parts (think of axle casing, stub axle, bearings, hub are all separate) whereas lots of modern cars have lots of more complex, expensive and factory assembled components. Take the bearing being integral with the hub for a discovery 3, etc. Therefore with the Defender setup it's a lot easier to introduce an error into the process that can cause premature failure. I wonder how many bearing failures of Britpart bearings are due to a wrong torque or getting grit inside during assembly, etc? The part gets the blame in any case.

    The large market for LR parts means that you're going to get the entire spectrum of businesses from high quality to low price

  8. Ok I re did the timing belt properly this time! Locked the flywheel and the pump, cam in correct position, belt on and tensioned it. Didn't assemble the front of the engine this time before having a go starting it and it's now running much smoother but snot quite itself yet, very very slight misfire under power but I haven't messed with the front of the injector pump to sort that yet, but it's still smoking like hell. But only white smoke, there's no coolant in the engine at all and slight white smoke is coming out the top hose port on the engine.

    Now what??

    You say you didn't do anything with the front of the injector pump. Just checking, did you torque the belt then tighten the 3 injection pump pulley bolts afterwards whilst the locking pin was still in?

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience. By using our website you agree to our Cookie Policy